Final determinations
State: York County must give addresses in 911 logs
May 27, 2009
The state Office of Open Records ruled recently that publicly released time response logs from York County's 911 Center must include where police or fire units were headed when they were dispatched. The office made the ruling Friday in response to an appeal by the York Daily Record/Sunday News. More than two months ago, the Daily Record/Sunday News asked the county for the logs with addresses. Read More…
Pa. backs New Era on autopsy reports
April 21, 2009
The state has ruled that Lancaster County must supply autopsy records in two cases to the Lancaster New Era. In addition, the Pennsylvania Office of Open Records has admonished the county for not complying with the state's Right to Know law when it rejected the newspaper's request.
Read More…
Read More…
Opinion: State must close open records loophole
April 10, 2009
It took no time at all, only about three months, for elected Pennsylvania officials to mount a highly significant challenge to the state's fledgling Right-to-Know Law. Most observers expected a push against what had been hailed by lawmakers last year as a comprehensive defense against efforts to keep the public in the dark, especially the practice of conducting secret deliberations before springing a decision upon citizens left to wonder how they got there. And, indeed, it appears Pennsylvania's reputation as a Land of Secrets remains in intact. Read More…
DEP challenges records ruling
April 10, 2009
The state's new Office of Open Records has been open four months and already it has received 278 requests for help in resolving disputes over what constitutes a government record. So far, the office has issued decisions in 75 of those disputes involving such entities as fire companies, school districts, parking authorities and two dozen state agencies. Three of those decisions were appealed to county courts. One recent decision could become one of the first court tests of the revised Right to Know Law and could be of interest to anyone who doesn't want to travel far to review government records. Read More…
Opinion: If requested, state should mail documents
April 10, 2009
The intent of Pennsylvania's Right to Know Law is clear: Public information should be available to the public in a timely fashion. But already we have a legal challenge on what exactly "available" means. Read More…
Pennsylvania has first test over access to records
April 08, 2009
In one of the first tests of a new Pennsylvania law intended to make state records more readily available to the public, the State Department of Environmental Protection was ordered on Tuesday to copy and mail out documents to people who request them, rather than force people to come to its offices in Harrisburg. Read More…
Opinion: OOR decision on 'draft' policy disappointing
April 07, 2009
In a disappointing decision, on March 23, 2009, the Office of Open Records found that a draft policy that was distributed to a school board for deliberation at a public meeting – and approved at that meeting – was not a public record. Read More…
Pa. newspaper group blasts open-records ruling
April 03, 2009
HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) — The Pennsylvania Newspaper Association has sharply criticized the state Open Records Office for a ruling that the group says would allow school boards and other agencies to conduct more public business behind closed doors. Read More…
Opinion: Office of Open Records issues damaging decision
April 02, 2009
The Office of Open Records (OOR) has dealt a blow to open government, apparently finding that a budget discussion among a quorum of a school board was not "deliberation" for Right to Know Law purposes because it was, in the words of the OOR, an "informal" discussion. If this decision stands, it could have terrible repercussions for the public's right to know. Read More…
PNA Legal: Our thoughts on the first decisions of the Office of Open Records
March 10, 2009
After reviewing the first “Final Determinations” issued by the Office of Open Records (OOR), we see some lessons in them for requesters and agencies. Not surprisingly, the decisions also raise some questions and concerns. Here are our thoughts on the first round of decisions. Read More…
The decisions are in ... New Open Records Office issues first “Final Determinations”
March 05, 2009
Since February 19, Pennsylvania’s Office of Open Records has issued 11 “final determinations” on open records disputes in the Commonwealth, and the results are mostly encouraging. These decisions are binding, unless appealed within 30 days. It is highly likely that some of these decisions will be appealed. Read More…
Records appeal turned down
February 25, 2009
The Office of Open Records denied a borough resident's request for records of inspections of two privately owned properties. The office also rejected an appeal from Quakertown School District Read More…
Ruling: Government employee birth dates are public records in Pa.
February 24, 2009
The new state Office of Open Records ruled on six appeals, offering access to government employee dates of birth, names of government contractor employees and school board committee reports. Read More…
Pa. open-records office: birth dates are public
February 24, 2009
HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) — Names of employees of government contractors and birth dates of government employees are public information, the state Office of Open Records has ruled in some of the first appeals under Pennsylvania's new Right-to-Know Law. Read More…


