Sunshine Act
Opinion: Recording restrictions not compliant with Sunshine Act
June 20, 2014
Q: A borough is considering a policy that would prohibit recording public meetings where no vote is scheduled to take place, and would require registration at least 48 hours in
advance in order to obtain council’s approval. The policy also limits the right to record to borough residents and taxpayers, and threatens prosecution under the Pennsylvania Wiretap Act for recording a public meeting without council’s express, prior approval. Is this compliant with the Sunshine Act? Read More…
advance in order to obtain council’s approval. The policy also limits the right to record to borough residents and taxpayers, and threatens prosecution under the Pennsylvania Wiretap Act for recording a public meeting without council’s express, prior approval. Is this compliant with the Sunshine Act? Read More…
PennLive puts Steelton council recording restriction to the test
June 16, 2014
STEELTON – It's not that the resolution restricting the use of cameras and recording devices wasn't in effect; Borough Council just didn't need to enforce it Monday night, council President Jeffery Wright said. Read More…
Commissioner: Two raises OK’d before vote violates law
June 14, 2014
SUNBURY — The paperwork to appoint and compensate Northumberland County assistant solicitor John Muncer and administrative assistant Janet Povish as acting chief clerks had already been completed before a vote was to be taken at a public meeting that was canceled when a commissioner landed in the hospital.
Read More…
Read More…
Wolf calls closed City Council meeting concerns ‘nonsense‘
June 13, 2014
Tom Wolf, the Democratic nominee for governor, today described as "nonsense" concerns about his closed-door City Hall meeting yesterday with a quorum of Philadelphia City Council members.
Read More…
Read More…
Attorney: Solicitor violated Sunshine Act
June 13, 2014
NEW CASTLE — A Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association lawyer said Mahoning Township’s solicitor violated state law by forbidding recording at a hearing this week. Attorney Louis Perrotta conducted a conditional use zoning hearing before township supervisors for wellpads and a compressor station Tuesday and told the audience to turn off any recording devices. Read More…
Former councilman drops Sunbury Sunshine Act suit
June 11, 2014
SUNBURY — A former city councilman has filed documents in Northumberland County Court to terminate a lawsuit he brought against Sunbury and Mayor David Persing. Read More…
Media law experts: Coal Twp. tabled 'no recording' idea is not reasonable
June 10, 2014
COAL TOWNSHIP — Media law experts agree that a now-tabled policy proposal restricting citizens from audio recording the Coal Township Board of Commissioner's public agenda sessions would not hold up under judicial review Read More…
McKeesport school district fined $250 for violating open meeting order
June 09, 2014
The McKeesport Area School District must pay $250 toward an education fund within 30 days for its failure to announce an executive session with its board of directors in April.
Read More…
Read More…
Phila. council ignoring Sunshine laws, watchdog group says
June 08, 2014
PHILADELPHIA (CBS) — A state watchdog group says Philadelphia City Council willfully ignored Pennsylvania’s open-meetings law this past week by gathering behind closed doors — not once, but twice. Read More…
School fires teacher, refuses to announce name
June 07, 2014
The New Kensington-Arnold School Board recently fired a music teacher, about a year after he was suspended while awaiting disposition of criminal charges of illegal gun and drug possession, but may have violated the Sunshine Act by not identifying him by name at the public meeting where the decision was made. Read More…
Chief challenges recording at town’s public meeting
June 07, 2014
SANDY LAKE — A Sandy Lake council meeting took a turn focusing on the public’s rights Wednesday night. Police Chief Donald Oakes stopped a reporter from recording the meeting after stating that members of council must be notified prior to being recorded. Read More…
Board must disclose furloughed employee names
June 05, 2014
Q: A local school board furloughed several employees at a public meeting without disclosing their names. The board voted using employee numbers only, and cited concerns about employee privacy to support its position. Isn’t the agency required to release the names of the employees who are the subject of official action? Read More…
Steelton requires notice before recording, photographing council meetings
May 23, 2014
STEELTON — Markis Millberry stood up in the meeting to photograph the Steelton Borough Council prior to the swearing in of a new police officer. Interrupting the police chief's ceremony, Council President Jeffrey Wright asked Millberry to not record it and to put away his cellphone, reminding the Steelton resident about the borough's resolution requiring prior notice in writing before meetings if anyone wants to record or photograph a meeting.
Read More…
Read More…
Pa. measure would require recording of secret meetings
March 12, 2014
HARRISBURG — Under legislation before the House, state and local government agencies would be required to record secret meetings so that, if challenged by citizens, a court later could determine whether the body violated the state's open meetings law.
Read More…
Read More…
State of county, ethics before council
February 23, 2014
Luzerne Council Council is scheduled to meet in closed-door executive session before the meeting to discuss proposed revisions to the county ethics code, but some council members are backing Kingston resident Brian Shiner’s argument that the matter should be discussed in public to comply with the state’s open-meeting law. Read More…
Quasi-judicial deliberations may be private
February 20, 2014
Q: A zoning hearing board heard testimony on a zoning application, took public comment, and then met privately to discuss the application and public comment. After the private discussion, the board voted publicly to approve the application. Can they do that? Read More…
Munhall OKs loan, but may not need it
February 20, 2014
Munhall council unanimously accepted a bid proposal for a tax anticipation note loan from a private lender on Wednesday, although there's a chance the borough may not need to borrow the money. The vote came after the borough manager read the four loan bids submitted to the borough, which for all intents and purposes is a “cure” to the potential violation of Pennsylvania's Sunshine Act that occurred when the finance committee opened and discussed the bids during a closed-door session last week. Read More…
Luzerne County Council stands by decision for executive session
February 20, 2014
The reason Luzerne County Council cited in calling a secret discussion about proposed changes to the ethics code does not merit an executive session, a media law expert said Wednesday. Read More…
Munhall officials may have violated Pennsylvania's Sunshine Act
February 15, 2014
Munhall officials may have violated Pennsylvania's Sunshine Act when they opened and discussed sealed bids during a closed-door finance committee meeting on Feb. 10, according to a media law expert. Read More…
Council action should have come at public session, PNA attorney says
February 13, 2014
ELLWOOD CITY — When Ellwood City Council changed the deadline for accepting applications for vacancies on its boards and commissions in December, the action should have been taken at a public session, according to an attorney for the Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association. Read More…
Monroe Borough council holds unadvertised meeting
January 31, 2014
An unadvertised meeting between Monroe Borough and Township officials on Jan. 17 to discuss the logistics of a planned levee was likely a violation of the Sunshine Act, according to Melissa Melewsky, media law council for the Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association. Read More…
Video recordings of Northumberland County meetings to be on website
January 31, 2014
SUNBURY — Northumberland County public meetings will be recorded on video and later uploaded to the Internet for county residents to view at their leisure. The practice started with Tuesday's 40-minute commissioners meeting, which can now be viewed by clicking a link on the home page of the county's website. Read More…


